Read the short editorial excerpt below (English). Then, in a 160–220 word response, identify three factual…

Questão

Read the short editorial excerpt below (English). Then, in a 160–220 word response, identify three factual statements and two opinion statements in the excerpt; explain how the author mixes facts and opinions; and evaluate whether the argument is persuasive and balanced, citing textual evidence. Excerpt: "The new tax increase will raise $2.4 million for the downtown library expansion. Citizens report longer wait times at branches, and some claim the plan favors wealthy neighborhoods."

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Facts: (1) 'will raise $2.4 million', (2) 'for the downtown library expansion', (3) 'citizens report longer wait times' — these are specific, potentially verifiable claims. Opinions: (1) 'some claim the plan favors wealthy neighborhoods'; (2) the editorial’s negative framing of the tax. The author pairs a concrete figure with unquoted reports and hearsay; without sources or balanced voices the argument is only partially persuasive. To be balanced, the piece should cite data sources, named respondents, and counterarguments.

Explicação

A resposta identifica claramente três afirmações factuais e duas opiniões, demonstrando a capacidade de distinguir entre dados verificáveis e interpretações subjetivas. Além disso, a análise da mistura de fatos e opiniões revela a falta de fontes e contrapartidas, o que compromete a persuasão do argumento. A sugestão de incluir dados e vozes balanceadas reforça a necessidade de um debate mais completo e justo.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• Read the excerpt from a city page: "A municipal report states the public library processed 5,860 new checkouts in May…
• Read the short journalistic paragraph below and complete the tasks. Excerpt: "The City Council announced last week a…
• Read the editorial excerpt below and respond as instructed. Excerpt: "The school board reports a 12% budget increase for…
• Read the short op-ed excerpt below (English). Excerpt: "City records show 4,500 trees were planted last year. Residents…
• Read the editorial excerpt below from a local newspaper and complete the task that follows. Excerpt: "City statistics…
• Read the short op-ed excerpt below and write a 120–150 word response evaluating how the author mixes facts and opinions…

Todas as questões de Reflexão pós-leitura