Read the editorial excerpt below from a local newspaper and complete the task that follows. Excerpt: "City…

Questão

Read the editorial excerpt below from a local newspaper and complete the task that follows. Excerpt: "City statistics show that evening foot traffic in the downtown area fell by 18% last year after the main bus line reduced service. The council reports that three small businesses in that block closed during the same period. Many residents say the neighborhood has become unsafe at night and blame the reduced transit for the decline. One columnist argued that the council's budget cuts prioritize convenience for drivers over the needs of pedestrians. Several shop owners described the new street lighting as inadequate and claimed the council ignored their complaints. The writer concludes that unless officials restore frequent bus service, the area will continue to deteriorate." Task: Identify three statements from the excerpt that are factual and three that are opinion. For each statement you pick, write one short sentence explaining why it is a fact or why it is an opinion.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Model answer (example): Facts: 1) "Evening foot traffic... fell by 18% last year." — This is a fact because it gives a specific, measurable statistic that can be checked in the city statistics. 2) "The council reports that three small businesses in that block closed during the same period." — This is a fact because it cites an official report about a verifiable event. 3) "The main bus line reduced service." — This is a fact because it describes a concrete change in transit service that can be confirmed with transit schedules or agency records. Opinions: 1) "Many residents say the neighborhood has become unsafe at night and blame the reduced transit for the decline." — This is an opinion because it reports residents’ feelings and a causal judgment rather than an independently verified fact. 2) "One columnist argued that the council's budget cuts prioritize convenience for drivers over the needs of pedestrians." — This is an opinion because it expresses the columnist’s interpretation and evaluation of council priorities. 3) "The writer concludes that unless officials restore frequent bus service, the area will continue to deteriorate." — This is an opinion because it is a prediction and a value judgment about future outcomes, not a verifiable fact.

Explicação

A identificação de fatos e opiniões é fundamental para a análise crítica de textos. Fatos são informações verificáveis e objetivas, enquanto opiniões refletem interpretações e sentimentos pessoais. A distinção entre esses dois tipos de declarações ajuda a entender melhor o contexto e a argumentação apresentada no texto.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• Read the short opinion column below and then complete the task. "City buses carried 8.4 million passengers last year, a…
• Read the editorial excerpt below and complete the task. Excerpt: "City council unveiled a proposal to add a protected…
• Read the short news excerpt below and respond as instructed. Excerpt: "The city council approved a new curfew last night…
• Op-ed excerpt: "The city installed 12 kilometers of bike lanes last year. Ridership surveys show bicycle trips increased…
• Read the short news excerpt and identify two factual statements and two opinion statements. Explain your classification…
• Read the brief news-summary: "A city report states: 'Violent crime decreased 9% in the downtown area in 2024.' A…

Todas as questões de Compreensão geral e específica: leitura rápida (skimming, scanning)