Read the short community note below (English). Excerpt: "The town should keep the old cinema open as a…

Questão

Read the short community note below (English). Excerpt: "The town should keep the old cinema open as a community arts hub. Attendance rose 20% after low-cost tickets were introduced, local schools now use the space twice monthly, and nearby shops report more foot traffic." In 140–180 words, identify the author's main claim, list two supporting reasons from the excerpt, evaluate the strength of the evidence given for each reason, and conclude whether the evidence collectively makes a convincing argument.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Main claim: The author argues that the town should keep the old cinema open as a community arts hub. Two supporting reasons: (1) Attendance rose 20% after low-cost tickets were introduced; (2) Local schools use the space twice monthly (and nearby shops report increased foot traffic). Evaluation of evidence: The 20% attendance increase is quantitative and persuasive, but its strength depends on context (baseline attendance, time span, and whether the rise is sustained). School use is concrete and shows community value, though it is limited evidence if the number of events or student reach is small. The report of more foot traffic by shops is supportive but anecdotal without sales or visitor data. Conclusion: The evidence points in favor of the claim and is moderately convincing, but stronger, more detailed data (longer trends, attendance numbers by event, and economic indicators for shops) would make the argument more compelling.

Explicação

A resposta identifica claramente a tese central do autor e apresenta duas razões que a sustentam, demonstrando compreensão do texto. A avaliação da evidência é crítica e analítica, considerando a força e as limitações de cada argumento apresentado. A conclusão sintetiza a análise, reconhecendo a necessidade de dados adicionais para fortalecer a argumentação, o que demonstra um pensamento crítico sobre a eficácia da evidência.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• Write a 150–200-word persuasive forum post for your town's online community arguing that the closed downtown cinema…
• Read the short paragraph: 'After the city subsidized discounted student tickets, attendance by teens at the community…
• Read the short paragraph and, in one sentence, state the author's main claim in English. Paragraph: 'The local community…
• Read the brief editorial below. In English, (a) state the author's main argument in one sentence; (b) list two distinct…
• Read the short editorial below. "Our town library currently closes at 6 pm, which prevents many students from doing…
• Read the editorial excerpt below. Then identify the author's two main arguments and list two pieces of evidence or…

Todas as questões de Compreensão geral e específica: leitura rápida (skimming, scanning)