Read the short editorial below and then write a 6-sentence argumentative paragraph in English that (a) states…

Questão

Read the short editorial below and then write a 6-sentence argumentative paragraph in English that (a) states the author's main argument in one sentence, (b) evaluates two pieces of evidence the author gives and says whether they are sufficient, and (c) proposes one additional piece of evidence that would make the argument stronger. Editorial: "Our school should offer vegetarian lunches twice a week. Recent health reports link plant-based meals to lower cholesterol among adolescents, and a pilot menu last month showed improved concentration in two classrooms."

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

The author argues that the school should offer vegetarian lunches twice a week. The two cited supports are a general health report linking plant-based diets to lower cholesterol and a small pilot showing improved concentration; the report offers useful background but may not prove direct benefit for our students, and the pilot is promising but limited by sample size and duration. Together they suggest potential benefits but are not fully sufficient to mandate change. A stronger case would include longer-term local health data from our student population or a controlled study comparing concentration and health measures before and after adopting the menu. Adding cost analysis and student acceptance data would also address practical implementation concerns. Overall, targeted local evidence would make the argument more convincing.

Explicação

A resposta apresenta de forma clara o argumento principal do autor e analisa criticamente as evidências fornecidas, destacando suas limitações. Além disso, sugere uma nova evidência que poderia fortalecer o argumento, mostrando uma compreensão mais profunda do tema. Essa estrutura lógica e a análise crítica são essenciais em uma resposta dissertativa eficaz.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• Read the short opinion: "Our middle school's cafeteria started serving scratch-cooked lunches last term. Daily salad…
• Write a 120–160-word persuasive paragraph in English taking a clear stance on whether your school cafeteria should add…
• Read the short editorial below in English. In a brief paragraph (3–5 sentences), state the author's main argument and…
• Read the passage and then do three tasks in English: (a) state the author's main argument in one sentence; (b) list two…
• As student magazine editor, write a concise 10-sentence editorial arguing that the school cafeteria menu should be…
• Read the passage below in English. Then write a 6-sentence argumentative paragraph taking a clear position on replacing…

Todas as questões de Planejamento do texto: organização de ideias