Read the passage below and then: (a) state the author's main argument in one sentence, (b) name two pieces of…

Questão

Read the passage below and then: (a) state the author's main argument in one sentence, (b) name two pieces of evidence the author uses, and (c) explain which piece of evidence is stronger and why. Write your answer in English (3–5 sentences). Passage: 'Our school district piloted a mandatory community-service requirement last year. Volunteers reported better college applications and a survey showed 70% of students improved time-management skills. Local nonprofits noted an increase in volunteers able to complete tasks independently. Given these outcomes, the district should adopt the requirement for all high-school students.'

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

The district should adopt the mandatory community-service requirement for all high-school students. Two pieces of evidence are the survey showing 70% of students improved time-management skills and reports from local nonprofits that volunteers completed tasks more independently. The survey is the stronger evidence because it provides quantified results from many students, making the claim more generalizable; the nonprofits' observations are useful but more anecdotal and descriptive.

Explicação

A resposta apresenta de forma clara o argumento principal do autor e identifica duas evidências que sustentam essa argumentação. A análise da força das evidências é bem fundamentada, destacando a importância de dados quantitativos em comparação com relatos qualitativos. Essa abordagem torna a argumentação mais convincente e acessível, permitindo uma compreensão mais profunda dos resultados da pesquisa.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• During a school assembly, students listen to a speaker who argues that community service should be mandatory for all…
• Read the short paragraph and, in one sentence, state the author's main claim in English. Paragraph: 'The local community…
• Compose a persuasive paragraph on why students should participate in community service.
• Read the editorial excerpt: 'The youth center added free after-school classes. Weekly attendance rose from 45 to 130…
• Read the passage and then do three tasks in English: (a) state the author's main argument in one sentence; (b) list two…
• Write a 130–160-word argumentative paragraph in English taking a clear stance on whether schools should require students…

Todas as questões de Reflexão pós-leitura