Scenario: Two classmates argue about starting an after-school art club. Student A: 'An art club builds…

Questão

Scenario: Two classmates argue about starting an after-school art club. Student A: 'An art club builds creativity and belonging.' Student B: 'It adds costs and extra time for families.' Evaluate which position is stronger and justify your choice with at least two reasons referencing each student's points.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Model answer: I support Student A. Reasons for A: (1) promotes creativity that benefits learning; (2) creates belonging that improves wellbeing. Reasons from B to consider: (1) there are real costs; (2) scheduling may burden families. Overall, A's social and educational benefits outweigh B's concerns if the school seeks funding options and schedules thoughtfully.

Explicação

A resposta apresenta uma análise equilibrada, considerando os pontos positivos da proposta de Student A, que enfatiza benefícios sociais e educacionais, enquanto também reconhece as preocupações levantadas por Student B. A justificativa de que as vantagens superam os desafios, especialmente com soluções como financiamento e planejamento, demonstra um pensamento crítico e prático. Essa abordagem permite uma avaliação mais completa da situação, favorecendo a argumentação de A.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• At a school meeting one parent supports building a playground for safety and play; another opposes it because of cost…
• During a school meeting in Brazil, two students discuss whether sports should be part of the regular school schedule…
• Write a single-sentence topic statement that clearly claims after-school clubs increase student engagement, suitable as…
• Which type of supporting detail best shows that a proposed after-school club is affordable and realistic?
• Read the editorial: "Our school launched a free after-school coding club. Teachers report students submit more…
• Read the editorial excerpt: 'The youth center added free after-school classes. Weekly attendance rose from 45 to 130…

Todas as questões de Partilha de leitura, com mediação do professor