Questões BNCC EF09LI03

Residents are debating a plan to install a community fridge near the bus station. At the meeting, Maria says, “I support it because restaurants could donate safe, unsold meals instead of throwing them away.” Liam disagrees: “Food left outside could bring rats, so the council should spend its money only on street cleaning.” Dr. Reed, the local health officer, responds that the fridge would use sealed containers and daily temperature checks. She adds that similar programs in nearby towns did not report an increase in pests when volunteers followed collection schedules. Maria says these rules could make food sharing safer for families who need it.

Analyze the oral statements. Which sentence could a reporter use to represent the position defended by Maria and Dr. Reed while indicating the claim challenged in the discussion?

“Removing parking spaces will hurt local shops,” said Mr. Cole during a town meeting about a protected bike lane near the market. “Customers who carry heavy bags need to stop close to the stores.” Maya replied, “A street is not only for drivers. Many people arrive by bus, on foot, or by bicycle, and some avoid this area because traffic feels unsafe. If more residents can reach the market safely, shops may receive more visitors.” Mr. Cole answered that parking is essential for some customers. Maya agreed that delivery vehicles and people with limited mobility need access, but argued that this does not mean every visitor must depend on a car. The meeting continued with residents discussing how public space can serve different needs.

Analyze Maya’s position and compare it with the proposals below. Which proposal uses reasoning similar to hers?

Can a public library serve every resident if a borrowed book arrives late? In a recorded town meeting, Councilor Reed says late fines should remain because “people need a reason to return books on time.” Librarian Okafor disagrees. She explains that overdue notices and temporary borrowing limits already remind users, while fines can make families stop using the library after a small debt. Reed responds that removing fines would reward careless behavior. Okafor then mentions neighboring libraries that ended fines but kept due dates and account reminders; their staff did not report longer waiting lists for popular books. At the end, a teen speaker adds that readers should be responsible, but access to books should not depend on a family's ability to pay an unexpected fee.

Analyze the librarian’s reasoning in the meeting. How does she challenge Reed’s claim that fines are necessary?

Why are there more cameras in public places? During a local radio call-in show, listeners discuss a proposal to install CCTV cameras around the city’s main bus terminal.

Host: “Supporters say cameras can reduce crime. Critics worry about privacy and misuse.”

Caller 1: “I’m in favor. Last year, a nearby city added cameras and reported fewer robberies. Cameras also help identify suspects quickly. If you’re not doing anything wrong, you shouldn’t be afraid.”

Caller 2: “I disagree. A drop in robberies can happen for other reasons, like more police patrols or better street lighting. Before spending on cameras, the city should publish clear data and a plan for who can access the recordings. Safety matters, but people shouldn’t be watched all the time just because a place is crowded.”

Analyze the call-in show excerpt and identify how Caller 2 challenges Caller 1’s main argument for CCTV cameras.

When the city council announced a new bike lane along Riverside Avenue, the discussion quickly moved beyond traffic rules. Supporters said the lane would give teenagers and workers a safer way to travel, reduce air pollution, and make short trips faster than sitting in traffic. One local shop owner added that cyclists often stop more easily than drivers, which can increase sales. Opponents replied that the street is already narrow and that removing one car lane could create longer jams during rush hour. They also argued that not everyone can ride a bike because of age, distance, or physical condition. In response, supporters pointed out that the project does not replace buses or walking paths; it only offers another option for people who want a different form of transport.

Analyze the text and identify the statement that best strengthens the supporters' point of view.

As the crowd waited for the weekend fair to open, the town radio aired a short interview with two guests. The event organizer said, “We cannot keep handing out hundreds of plastic cups and forks every day. The fair brings people together, but it also leaves bags full of waste. If we offer reusable cups and ask food stalls to sort their trash, we can reduce the mess without making the event less fun.” A food vendor answered, “Some people think this will be too expensive, but the cost of cleaning up after the fair is already high. Small changes now can save money later and show respect for the community park.” The host then asked whether visitors would accept the new rules, and both guests agreed that clear signs and simple guidance would help people adapt quickly.

Analyze the interview and identify which position is defended about the fair’s new waste rules.

Read the short news-audio transcript and identify the positions defended and refuted.

Transcript: "Welcome to Green City News. Today we visit a community garden where volunteers explain urban farming benefits for local neighborhoods. Some residents say the garden takes up useful public space, but volunteers argue that it provides fresh food and brings neighbors together."

Based on the transcript, which position do the volunteers defend, and which claim do they refute?

In class, Mia says, “Solar power is clean.” Leo says, “Solar panels cost too much.”

What does Mia say? What does Leo say?